Brick-and-Mortar vs. Online: How Retailers Can Compete Without Racing to the Bottom
For years, brick-and-mortar retailers competed primarily with the store across town. Today, they are competing with virtually every retailer in the country.
A customer can stand inside your store, hold a product in their hand, talk to one of your salespeople for 20 minutes, and then pull out their phone and find what appears to be the same product online for $30 less.
That has fundamentally changed retail.
But that doesn't mean brick-and-mortar retail is dead. Far from it.
Physical retailers still have significant advantages over pure online sellers. The problem is that too many retailers try to compete with e-commerce businesses solely on price instead of leveraging the advantages they already have.
The goal shouldn't always be to beat the internet.
The goal should be to give the customer a reason to buy from you.
The Biggest Advantage Brick-and-Mortar Has: The Customer Is Already There
Think about how valuable that is.
The customer drove to your location.
They walked through your door.
They are looking at your products.
They are talking to your salesperson.
They have already demonstrated buying intent.
An online retailer may have a lower advertised price, but the physical retailer has something incredibly valuable: the opportunity to create a relationship and close the transaction right now.
That opportunity shouldn't be underestimated.
Especially in the automotive aftermarket, many purchases involve far more than selecting a part number.
Customers have questions:
Will this fit my truck?
Will it work with my lift?
Do I need anything else?
Can I install it myself?
Will it affect another modification?
What's the warranty?
What happens if something goes wrong?
A knowledgeable salesperson can answer those questions immediately and in the correct context.
That expertise has value.
The Advantages of Brick-and-Mortar Retail
Physical retailers have several advantages that online-only businesses have difficulty duplicating.
Immediate Gratification
The customer can buy the product and leave with it today.
No shipping delays.
No waiting three or four days if it’s in stock or at a local distributor.
No worrying whether the package will arrive damaged.
For many customers, getting the product immediately is worth paying a little more.
Product Knowledge
A strong salesperson can guide a customer toward the correct product instead of simply selling whatever SKU the customer searched for online.
That can reduce returns, improve customer satisfaction, and increase the likelihood the customer comes back.
In industries like automotive aftermarket, powersports, outdoor products, tools, RV, and sporting goods, this is an enormous advantage.
Knowledge sells.
Installation and Service
This may be one of the greatest opportunities for specialty retailers.
An online retailer can ship someone a suspension kit.
A local retailer can sell the suspension, install it, align the vehicle, recommend wheels and tires, and help the customer with their next upgrade.
The product may get the customer through the door.
The services and relationship create lifetime value.
The Ability to Upsell and Cross-Sell
A customer who goes online looking for one product often buys one product.
A customer inside a well-run retail store may discover five other things they didn't know they needed.
A salesperson selling a tonneau cover may also sell:
BedMat
Bed lighting
Floor liners
Steps
Tie-down equipment
Installation
Vehicle care products
That changes the economics of the transaction dramatically.
The question shouldn't only be, "Did we make enough margin on the tonneau cover?"
It should also be, "What was the total value of this customer transaction?"
Human Relationships
People still buy from people.
A customer who trusts a salesperson, installer, or store manager is much less likely to leave over a small price difference.
That relationship becomes especially important when something goes wrong.
It's easy to buy something online.
It's much more difficult to explain a complicated installation problem to a chatbot or return a 100-pound product halfway across the country.
A strong local retailer becomes an advisor, not simply a place that sells products.
Where Brick-and-Mortar Retailers Are at a Disadvantage
There are also very real disadvantages that retailers need to understand.
Ignoring them doesn't make them disappear.
Price Transparency
Twenty years ago, consumers had to visit multiple stores or make phone calls to compare prices.
Today it takes seconds.
Customers know what products cost before they walk into your store.
Retailers have to assume price transparency exists on virtually every recognizable SKU.
Trying to hide pricing or artificially inflate margins because you believe the consumer doesn't know better is increasingly difficult.
Higher Operating Costs
Physical retail comes with expenses that many online sellers either don't have or have at a different scale:
Rent.
Payroll.
Utilities.
Inventory.
Insurance.
Fixtures.
Showrooms.
Warehousing.
Local advertising.
These expenses mean a local retailer may simply be unable to match every online price while maintaining a healthy business.
And they shouldn't try.
Competing solely on price eventually becomes a race to zero margin.
Nobody wins that game for long.
Limited Inventory
An e-commerce retailer may show thousands of products available across multiple warehouses.
A brick-and-mortar retailer cannot reasonably stock everything.
That means inventory management becomes extremely important.
Retailers need to understand what customers in their market actually buy and keep their highest-velocity products available.
Your inventory should reflect your local customer.
Showrooming
This is probably one of the most frustrating parts of modern retail.
A customer walks into the store.
Your salesperson educates them.
They touch the product.
They ask questions.
They decide what they want.
Then they pull out their phone and order it somewhere else.
Instead of getting angry about showrooming, retailers need a strategy for dealing with it.
And that's where price matching becomes interesting.
Stop Treating Price Matching Like an Attack on Your Margin
When a customer says, "I found this cheaper online."
Many salespeople immediately become defensive.
That's the negative reaction the consumer must not see.
The customer just gave you an opportunity to save the sale.
They didn't quietly walk out of your store.
They told you exactly what is preventing them from buying.
That's valuable information.
A price-match request should trigger a conversation, not an argument.
The salesperson might respond: "Let's take a look at it."
That simple response changes the tone completely.
Now you're working with the customer instead of against them.
Compare the Real Price
One of the biggest mistakes is comparing only the advertised price.
The customer may say: "They have it online for $599, and yours is $649."
Fine.
Look at the entire transaction.
Is shipping included?
Is it actually in stock?
Is it the exact same part number?
Is the seller authorized?
Are there handling charges?
Will sales tax be collected?
How long will delivery take?
What happens if it arrives damaged?
What does returning it cost?
Does the warranty require an authorized retailer?
Once you compare the complete transaction, the price difference may become much smaller.
A $50 difference could become $15.
Now the conversation changes.
Price Matching Should Have Rules
Retailers should not automatically match every price found on the internet.
Create a defined price-match policy.
For example, the competing product should generally be:
An identical SKU.
Currently in stock.
Sold by an authorized retailer.
Available to the general public.
New, not used, open-box, refurbished, or liquidation inventory.
Comparable after shipping or other mandatory fees.
The retailer should also consider excluding marketplace sellers where the product's source cannot be verified.
This protects the business from competing against unauthorized sellers, distressed inventory, counterfeit products, and unrealistic pricing.
Know Your Minimum Acceptable Margin
This is where management needs to give salespeople some authority.
Your salesperson shouldn't have to track down the general manager every time someone asks for $20 off a $1,000 purchase.
Establish pricing guardrails.
For example:
At normal margin, the salesperson can approve the sale.
At a predetermined reduced margin, they can automatically match.
Below that level, management approval is required.
Below another level, you simply walk away.
Not every sale is worth making.
Revenue without margin doesn't build a healthy company.
Sometimes Don't Match the Price — Add Value Instead
Matching price isn't always necessary.
Let's say an online seller has the product for $599 and your store has it for $649.
Instead of immediately dropping the price $50, ask yourself what you can add that costs you less than $50 but feels worth more than $50 to the customer.
Maybe:
Free installation.
Discounted installation.
Priority scheduling.
A complimentary accessory.
Future store credit.
Free inspection.
Discounted alignment.
Discount on the customer's next purchase.
Now you've protected more margin while increasing the customer's perceived value.
This is where brick-and-mortar retailers can be creative.
Don't always discount the product.
Build a better transaction.
Turn Price Matching Into a Customer Acquisition Strategy
Retailers should think about price matching differently.
Customer Acquisition Cost.
Businesses spend money every day trying to acquire customers through:
Google Ads.
Meta ads.
Events.
Direct mail.
Email marketing.
Sponsorships.
Influencers.
Promotions.
If giving up $30 of gross profit converts someone into a customer who could spend $3,000 with you over the next several years, that $30 may be one of the cheapest customer acquisition investments you ever make.
But only if you actually capture and develop the customer.
If you price-match the product, ring them up as a "cash customer," and never collect their information, you've wasted much of the opportunity.
Capture:
Name.
Email.
Phone number.
Vehicle information.
Product interests.
Purchase history.
With the customer's permission, that information can then become part of your CRM and marketing strategy.
Now you haven't just sold a product.
You've acquired a customer.
That distinction matters.
Manufacturers Have a Role in This Too
Manufacturers also need to understand what their retail partners are facing.
You cannot ask brick-and-mortar dealers to invest in:
Inventory.
Displays.
Employees.
Training.
Showrooms.
Events.
Installation equipment.
Local marketing.
And then allow uncontrolled online discounting to destroy their margins.
Brands need to pay attention to channel health.
That can include strong authorized-dealer programs, consistent advertised-pricing policies where legally appropriate, monitoring unauthorized sellers, sensible distribution strategies, and ensuring different channels have enough margin to support the work they do.
A healthy manufacturer needs healthy retailers.
If every transaction becomes a bidding war for the lowest price, eventually the company’s providing education, installation, customer service, inventory, and local support disappear.
That isn't good for the consumer either.
Use the Internet Instead of Fighting It
The best brick-and-mortar retailers aren't going to be purely brick-and-mortar.
They're going to be omnichannel retailers.
Your physical store and digital presence should work together.
Customers should be able to:
Research online.
Check availability.
Ask questions.
Schedule an installation.
Purchase online.
Pick up in store.
Request a quote.
Text the store.
Read reviews.
Then walk through your door already knowing who you are.
The battle isn't really brick-and-mortar versus e-commerce anymore.
It's about giving customers the ability to buy however they want to buy.
The Retailer That Wins Doesn't Necessarily Have the Lowest Price
Consumers certainly care about price.
But consumers don't buy only price.
They buy convenience.
They buy knowledge.
They buy confidence.
They buy speed.
They buy service.
They buy relationships.
And they buy solutions.
If your only competitive advantage is price, someone will eventually sell it cheaper.
Brick-and-mortar retailers have to understand that their greatest asset isn't necessarily what's sitting on the shelf.
It's everything surrounding that product.
Your employees.
Your knowledge.
Your installation capabilities.
Your inventory.
Your reputation.
Your relationships.
Your ability to solve a customer's problem today.
And when a customer pulls out their phone and says, "I found it cheaper online," don't automatically see that as a problem.
See it for what it really is:
A customer standing in your store, product in hand, telling you exactly what you need to overcome to earn their business.
That's a sales opportunity.
Use it.
My website: www.michaeltimmonsgg.com
My LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/miketimmons
Comments